Ten Years Hence: The End of Privacy – How Intimacy Became Data and How to Stop It
This week’s lecture in Ten Years Hence will feature Danielle Citron, Jefferson Scholars Foundation Schenck Distinguished Professor in Law at the University of Virginia School of Law. Ms. Citron’s lecture is entitled, “The End of Privacy: How Intimacy Became Data, and How to Stop It.” In her book, Hate Crimes in Cyberspace (2014), and a series of law review articles that informed it, Ms. Citron documents the significant harms caused by various types of cyber stalking, cyber mob attacks, and more.
Read the biography of the speaker here: The End of Privacy: How Intimacy Became Data and How to Stop It
Read the event recap, watch the video, or listen to the podcast below.
- Privacy is fundamentally important to the human person because it lets us experiment with who we are, and this process of self-revelation allows us to forge and form close relationships and friendships with others. (11:50).
- “Information about our bodies, about our sexuality and gender, information about our close relationships and our innermost thoughts, is being collected, used, shared, and monetized in ways we would never imagine.” (Danielle Citron 13:11)
- “When we feel ourselves that we’re in control of who has access to our bodies and our intimate lives, then we feel like we have respect for our choices and our self-esteem.” (Danielle Citron 18:18)
- “What we’re seeing is that privacy invaders are particularly focused on spying on, exploiting, extorting, manufacturing…and then displaying intimate information, especially nude photos.” (Danielle Citron 19:49)
- With the widespread availability and relatively low price of portable, small-sized cameras with WiFi connections, video voyeurism has become a particularly difficult problem to tackle. (22:27)
- Because of Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which provides an immunity to site operators in the U.S. for hosting user-generated content, entire websites are able to devote themselves to, and make money off of, the posting of non-consensual pornography with impunity (27:26).
- “Researchers have found that there are over 80,000 deep fake videos online, and 96 percent of those are deep fake sex videos, and over 98 percent of those videos are of women’s faces being inserted into porn, so it’s very gendered.” (Danielle Citron 29:12)
- The U.S. by and large treats the collection, use, and sharing of intimate data as a consumer-protection matter. The presumption is permission to collect, use, monetize, and sell said data, and there are only a few barebones procedural protections for individuals under the law. (34:49)
- “The deck is really stacked against [privacy-violation] victims being able to have some sense of justice in their own hands.” (Danielle Citron 42:49)
- Invasions of intimate privacy need to be looked at through the framework of civil rights and modern civil rights law. (42:52).
From time immemorial, privacy has been an important, necessary condition for human development. The ability to experiment with who we are, explore our innermost thoughts and desires, and to set boundaries around relationships allows us to develop as full persons engaging in and with greater society. Unfortunately, technological change and lack of legal protections has led privacy to come under assault, with our most intimate information subject to data collection, harvesting, and selling to third parties, as well as surveillance by private actors out to extort. Exploring this dangerous trend and developing a robust framework for securing and protecting our intimate data grounded in civil rights law was the topic that Danielle Citron, Jefferson Scholars Foundation Schenck Distinguished Professor in Law, discussed in the final talk of 2021’s Ten Years Hence series.
Going on an adult website, using a dating or fitness app, or just using a search engine to query medical information will subject a person to ad tracking and data harvesting. Intimate information about one’s sexuality, gender, or body becomes monetized and sold. In countries like the United States, such data collection is treated as a consumer protection matter: The presumption is that companies and sites have permission to gather, and sell personal data, with only a few barebones legal protections for individuals.
At the same time, technological change has made both video voyeurism and non-consensual pornography growing problems for the protection of privacy and intimate data. Portable cameras with WiFi connections are now smaller (and thus easier to hide) and cheaper than ever before, leading women in many parts of the world to take precautions when using public restrooms, for example. At the same time, sites devoted entirely to so-called “revenge porn” have proliferated and made profits off of non-consensual pornography, and in the U.S. are able to do so under the protection of Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which grants immunity to sites when it comes to user-generated content. What’s worse, many individuals now find themselves a subject of a “sextortion” campaign, where a malicious actor gets hold of intimate photos or video and threatens to share it with a victim’s loved ones or coworkers unless the victim provides more intimate content or money.
The way forward, Citron argued, is to avoid piecemeal legislation aimed at tackling mere bits or parts of this phenomenon, and instead focus on addressing the core issue of intimate data and privacy protection legally by framing and recognizing it as a civil right, a course correction which will necessarily involve reform of Section 230. At the same time, legal remedies will only take us so far. Tech companies, especially social media platforms, need to move away from the “move fast and break stuff” mindset when it comes to protecting users’ privacy, and we as users need to educate ourselves on the fundamental importance of intimate privacy and instill in ourselves respect for others when it comes to the issue.
View the discussion recorded on Friday, April 30, 2021, with Professor Jim O’Rourke and special guest Danielle Citron.
Listen to the discussion wherever, whenever, on The ThinkND Podcast:
Register to participate in future events.